Loading consolidated registers and recipes...
Error loading progress database. Ensure that docs/dashboard_data.json is compiled and generated correctly.
0
Total Sources Logged
0
Swept / Ingested Sources
0
Total Evidence Claims
0
Compiled Recipes
Evidence Quality Signal Live counts from the Evidence Register — full review in the QA / QC Flags tab ▶ Open QA / QC Flags tab
TOTAL EV UNITS
—
VERIFY-FLAGS
—
UNREVIEWED
—
LOW CONFIDENCE
—
BY USE ROLE
—
Global Nature-based Solutions Comparison High-level evidence metrics compiled across all active NbS recipes
| Nature-based Solution | Total Sources | Swept / Ingested | Evidence Claims | T4 Suitability Mappings | T3 Climate Hazard Links | T6 Scorecard Outcomes & Costing |
|---|
▼ Suitability Families & Methodology Progress Matrix
Click to collapse/expand| NbS / Suitability Family Variant | T4 Suitability Mappings | Evidence Claims | T3 Climate Hazard Links | T6 Scorecard Outcomes & Costing | Status |
|---|
Filter Overview Scope
Select a Nature-based Solution or sub-practice family to filter the statistics and flow diagram.
Evidence Sourcing & Translation Flow Diagram Hover over nodes to trace lineage, or switch to the Reviewed Sources Grid view.
Filter Target Tables:
| Reviewed Source | Tier | Geography / Context | T4 Suitability | T3 Hazards | T6 Costing | Variables Extracted |
|---|
Sources Extraction Status per NbS
Swept / Extracted
Pending / Sweeps remaining
Evidence Benchmark Tiers
100%
Traceable
Represented Study Countries / Contexts
Literature Sourcing Methods
Family Title
Product typeFamily definition details.
Dominant Limiting Factor
Limiting factor description.
Grouping Rationale
Rationale text.
▼ T4 Suitability Variable Mappings
Click to collapse/expand
Dimension:
| Variable | Dimension | Default Weight | Standard Dataset | Response Function / Params | Evidence Reconciliation & Justification | Action |
|---|
▼ Verbatim Evidence Claims
Click header to collapse/expand
▼ T3 Climate Hazard Mitigation Links
Click to collapse/expand
Hazard:
| Hazard | Farming Context | Mitigation Potential | Mechanism & Evidence | Action |
|---|
▼ T6 Scorecard Outcomes & Costing
Click to collapse/expand
Type:
| Outcome / Cost Indicator | Value range | Confidence | Mechanism & Evidence | Action |
|---|
▼ VONT Variable Ontology Register
Click to collapse/expand
Group:
| Variable ID | Label | Group | Canonical Unit | Min meaningful resolution | Sensitivity |
|---|
▼ T1 Spatial Dataset Registry
Click to collapse/expand
Access:
| Dataset ID | Dataset Name | Coverage | Format | Access Type / asset ID | Limitations |
|---|
Evidence & Methodology Network Diagram Force-directed relational network showing how literature sources translate to biophysical variables, suitability families, and target recipe tables.
Filter Settings
Visible Graph Entities:
Lineage Explorer
Hover over any node to highlight its connected neighborhood. Drag nodes to explore relationships. Use mouse scroll to Zoom and Pan. Double-click to pin/unpin nodes.
💡 Drag nodes to explore. Scroll to Zoom. Double-click any node to pin/unpin it.
Node Inspector
Hover or select a node in the network to inspect its metadata, details, and verbatim literature claims.
⚐ QA / QC — VERIFY-FLAG review Every EV row flagged by the relationship-verify pass — work through these before any threshold is trusted
AI INCLUDED — AI accepted it; spot-check it's faithful (AI-passed view)
MISMATCH — AI-flagged: a value contradicted the quote (auto-corrected)
UNSUPPORTED — AI-flagged: a value the quote never contained (stripped)
To review: set your handle → choose ok (keep) or drop (remove) + a reason → Apply & submit to main writes it to the register, re-gates, and opens a PR that auto-merges on green CI.
No live server? Use Download decisions CSV →
review.py apply.
Reason codes — what each means
smuggled_number — number not in this quote
table_error — mangled / mis-stitched table (cells merged across rows, garbled values)
wrong_variable — mis-labelled variable (SOM≠SOC)
wrong_practice — wrong NbS/practice (reforestation, pure forestry, carbon-only)
species_envelope — per-species range, not a practice rule (retag species-specific + keep, don't drop)
off_scope — not a suitability claim (site descriptors, wrong crop)
wrong_table — soft enabling-env → T3/M2b/next-steps, not T4
constrained_aoi — source only covers part of the land (e.g. “marginal land”) → understates where the NbS can go; don't use to set extent
quote_too_narrow — too little context
relationship_missed — suitability curve/directionality in source but not captured
insufficient_context — no caption/context or screengrab failed → cannot review
unusable_value — variable named but no usable rule: weight with no scale (“5 out of what?”) or land cover with no class list
speculative_evidence — speculation/assumption, not first/second-hand
false_flag — verifier wrong → keep (ok)
accepted_correction — fix accepted → ok
confirmed_pass — AI pass was correct → ok (passed mode)
missed_error — AI missed it → drop (passed mode)
other — explain in the note
Filters
ⓘ how the filters work
The Filter bar (right) has three orthogonal toggles, each with a live count — combine them for any permutation:
Origin (Any / ⚑ AI-flagged / ✓ AI-passed) · Reviewed by me (Any / Not / Yes) · Reviewed by others (Any / Not / Yes).
Common views: To review = me Not · 2nd opinion = me Not + others Yes · your own calls = me Yes, then the My call sub-filter (✓ Kept / ⚑ Queried / 🗑 Dropped).
Everything also follows the SCOPE below (Practice · Sub-practice · Evidence type · channel · access) — change any and all counts update together.
⚠ Gaps / 📊 Stats — buttons top-right.
Scope
Apply & submit
Filter
📚 Stocktake & Tools
Catalogues of what's out there: Peer-reviewed = 220 sources from the pre-repo OpenAlex search (C/I/D benchmark); Tools / methods = the in-repo TOOL_tool_registry (codebases · platforms · method frameworks). In-repo paper-first / grey sweeps live under Discovery & Search Log.
Discovery & Search Log PRISMA-lite funnels, AGROVOC search queries, and borderline edge-case triage decisions.
Practice (NbS)
Table / Step
Sub-Practice
▼ Evidence Discovery Coverage Audit Matrix
Click to collapse/expand
Status:
Practice & variant follow the Practice / Sub-practice chips below.
ℹ️ What this matrix shows & how to use it — click to expand
What it is. A coverage map of evidence discovery — how far the pipeline has progressed for every combination of sub-practice, recipe table and source type. Each row is an NbS sub-practice (suitability family). Each column group is a recipe table it feeds: T4 suitability (where the NbS can establish), T3 hazard links (which climate hazards it mitigates), T6 outcomes & costing. Each group splits into four source channels — Stock (benchmarked stocktake), Lit (updated peer-reviewed), Grey (reports / project docs), Tools (methods / code). So one cell answers: for this sub-practice × table × channel, how far has discovery got, and how much is reviewed?
How to use it. Scan for gaps (what still needs searching, extracting or reviewing). Click a cell's numbers → its evidence units + verify/review state; click its stage pip → the exact search protocol behind it. The Status dropdown above and the Practice / Sub-practice chips filter which rows appear. Key below:
Two numbers
#direct — sources from a family-targeted search
+#generic — reached via the practice-wide parent search
Stage pip
the furthest stage reached — a source moves through them in order. Green = direct (a search aimed at this sub-practice). slate · gen = the generic practice-wide parent search reached it (shown when no direct search has run yet).
1 · Searched — a discovery search was run for this cell and its protocol logged (search terms · criteria · limits · counts).
2 · Extracted — at least one evidence unit has been pulled from a source into the register here.
3 · Verified — those units passed the relationship-verify pass (each number / relationship checked against its verbatim quote).
4 · Reviewed — every unit in the cell has had at least one human decision (ok / drop). Partial review shows as Extracted or Verified, with the coverage in the review bar below.
Pip colour
stage reached
in progress
not started
Review bar
share of the cell's evidence units by review depth —
unreviewed
1 review
2+ reviews
Click
the numbers → that cell's evidence units + their verify / review state. The stage pip → that cell's search protocol (terms · criteria · limits · counts · ruleset).
| NbS & Suitability Family Variant ▲ | T4 Suitability Mappings Stock · Lit · Grey · Tools |
T3 Hazard Links Stock · Lit · Grey · Tools |
T6 Outcomes & Costing Stock · Lit · Grey · Tools |
|---|
Search protocol
⚠️ Report missing evidence
Flag a variable / figure / table you expected but that isn't in the register (e.g. "Figure 7 lists slope but there's no slope row"). Logged to the in-repo gaps register (pipeline/metrics/gaps.csv) to feed a re-extraction sweep.
PRISMA-lite Discovery Funnel
Queries & Databases Screened
Discovered and Registered Sources
Filter Category:
Stage S logged in a discovery log · E registered in the source register · Xn n evidence claims extracted · ⚑ claims flagged for review · R human-reviewed. Filled = done, hollow = not yet.
Tier = source credibility (High / Medium / Low) from the screening rubric (evidence strength · transparency · venue · context · recency).
"Scholar Search" + 0 claims = a source that was logged during search but never registered/extracted (no DOI recorded), so the link falls back to a Google Scholar lookup. These are search candidates, not part of the evidence base yet.
Tier = source credibility (High / Medium / Low) from the screening rubric (evidence strength · transparency · venue · context · recency).
"Scholar Search" + 0 claims = a source that was logged during search but never registered/extracted (no DOI recorded), so the link falls back to a Google Scholar lookup. These are search candidates, not part of the evidence base yet.
| Source ID | DOI / Link | Tier | Claims | Scope / Context | Extracted Key Variables / Target Hazards | Stage |
|---|
Evidence Claims for Source:
| Evidence ID | Variable | Relationship / Rules | Context | Verbatim Quote / Assertion | Page | Evidence Type |
|---|
Source Metadata JSON
Borderline & Triage Decisions (Human-in-the-Loop Review)
| Decision | Category / Source | Ambiguity / Reasoning | Proposal & Context Boundary Alignment |
|---|
Last compiled: 2026-06-12
•
Git commit:
abcdefg